19/04/2026
Having read the draft Section 10 scheme, the Agri EC / EC RPO comments, and other submissions, one thing is clear: everyone agrees urgency matters. Agri EC is absolutely right to push for urgent gazetting of the scheme, rapid appointment of the Committee and Chairperson, and pre-emptive vaccination outside outbreak areas as soon as possible. That urgency is real and necessary.
But the question I believe we now need to ask is bigger than urgency:
Will the proposed framework, even if gazetted quickly, actually work across the full farming reality of the Eastern Cape and South Africa?
The draft still contains conditions such as boundary fencing with registered coordinates, owner-funded authorised vet or AHT costs, and a scheme that is voluntary in name but may later become mandatory. Cape Eastern Livestockโs submission argues that these provisions may be achievable for stronger formal commercial systems, but not necessarily for communal, smallholder, mixed and less-resourced farming communities.
That is where I believe the real debate lies.
Agri ECโs comments make an important contribution on speed and structure, but they also leave many critical issues to the future Committee and SOP process, while supporting deletion of the public-funding clause and retaining owner-paid authorised vet / AHT costs.
So the question is not only:
How quickly can we gazette the framework?
The deeper question is:
Can the framework, once gazetted, be accessed, afforded and implemented fairly across all farming communities โ not only the stronger commercial farmer?
I support urgency.
But I also believe urgency without practical inclusion will create another layer of compliance for some, and another barrier for others.
This is a debate worth having โ respectfully, practically, and with the full demographic of the livestock sector in mind.
Think high Risk areas?
Think access to vaccine?
Think financial constraints?
Think lack of bio security?
We live in a diverse landscape where people think and act differently!
See questions in comments.
Letโs unpack this as it unfolds before us! And letโs see whether the leaders in industry have their feet on the ground, or are they just driving a desk ?