08/06/2026
The irony is not lost on me. One of my clients recently asked me what my favorite social media platform was. The question stumped me, because I don’t really like any of them anymore.
I used to love Instagram, back when it was over-filtered pics of food and cats. But honestly, I think marketing (and a touch of corporate greed) ruined it. I know that sounds disingenuous coming from a marketer. But there were no barriers to access for marketers. No way to prevent our feeds from becoming ads and product placement machines. There were ways to incentivize good content baked in (likes, follows), but nowhere near enough disincentive for the unnecessary or downright bad.
The result? People started throwing spaghetti at the wall to see what would stick, making every video with every imaginable ounce of relevance to their product they could. Whether the algorithm rewarded it or not, that volume became the expectation for businesses.
When you’re brought on as a social media manager, frequency matters as much as quality. This is a “keep up or fade away” place.
After a while of thinking about my client’s question, I eventually responded with: Reddit. Why? Because Reddit makes it harder to market. You can’t just hop onto any thread and push your product. You can’t just share only new posts angled at selling. Reddit has a public reputation score called “Karma” influenced by up-votes or down-votes of your contribution (and Redditors hate spam).
So on Reddit you are incentivized as a marketer to provide ad much VALUE as possible. Not just saturate screens, jump on trends, or post a certain amount at certain times.
That sort of system results in more thoughtful marketing, I think. Most people I know go to Reddit when they want to avoid bu****it. And I guess I like my social media as bu****it-free as possible.
I’m not saying there isn’t junk on Reddit or brilliant marketing on Instagram. And there’s a lot of science and effort that goes into social planning for Meta. It’s just that one has a better system for checks and balances, imho.
Rant over. On a side note, make sure you pull those eyes away from a screen today and go touch some grass. It�