07/07/2025
Overdependence on AI = Brain Atrophy.
That was the gist of a recent conversation I had with a friend of mine. We agreed that AI had merit in improving efficiency of processes and was handy in evaluating data -- yet there were definitely concerns about the source and inputs of the data AI used. But our biggest issue was the rampant use of AI for everyday simple tasks that was beginning to impede individuals' simple ability to read, write, and exhibit critical thinking.
The term we agreed upon was BRAIN ATROPHY.
We discussed how AI overdependence is beginning to affect workplace for day-to-day outputs, customer interactions/client relations, and big picture strategic planning.
AI has become pervasive and is popping up in every aspect of our lives and work, furthering our overuse and dependency.
Some examples of overdependence on AI in both personal & professional realms we discussed were:
* Use of AI to summarize an email - I want to read the words the sender used because my EXPERIENCE allows me to see subtle nuances that AI cannot interpret.
* Use of AI to create a document, write a social media post, or PR that sounds just like everyone else's.
* Use of AI to (re)write grant responses resulting in flowery nonsense which fail to answer specifications and grossly exceed allowable word count. (Tip: reviewers don't want to read all that, and after they've read 100+ they recognize AI patterns which costs you credibility!)
* Mindlessly depending on AI "research" or statistics without reviewing multiple sources, relevancy, and areas of expertise on the subject matter.
* The blatant (and deceptive) use of AI in creative endeavors on both the personal and professional levels (I'm sure there will be ethical questions raised on this matter in the future .. especially with incidents like Adrian Brody being awarded the Oscar for his AI-augmented performance over Timothée Chalamet's performance after years of voice training to speak and sing like Bob Dylan and even learning to play guitar.)
We viewed all of these as cheating - diminishing professional and creative abilities.
AI use in creative endeavors was a hot button as we are avid supporters of the arts. Using AI to write a novel or poem does NOT make an author. Even if you came up with a 'concept', half-written or outlined story but fed it to AI to finish (in the style of ___ author/book series) -- YOU did not write it. You are not a musician if you did not write the song lyrics or musical score -- and don't even play an instrument. You are not an artist if you verbally told AI to create an image with XYZ. All of these scenarios are "shortcuts" in which the self-proclaimed artist is cheating both their audience and themselves by not actually investing the time and effort into developing their skills and talent.
If you're a marketer with a small budget needing a little jingle for an ad .. ok, fine .. use AI for that. But if you are positioning yourself as an ARTIST .. don't cheat. It reminds me of the poser duo Milli Vanilli: 'Oh don't you know it's true .. you're gonna get busted too!'
In thinking about employees' overdependence on AI in the job place, my friend and I discussed many issues about how companies are at risk of their proprietary information getting stolen. We wondered what safeguards R&D divisions were taking?
This article has many great points to further this discussion, but I saw that he also uses the term Brain Atrophy! He makes several other important points in how AI-dependency is negatively affecting businesses .. here were a few that jumped out at me:
* Relying heavily on AI can lead to the deskilling of human strategists, diminishing their ability to make independent judgments.
* AI systems might unintentionally make discriminatory decisions or violate privacy regulations. Human oversight is essential to ensure compliance with legal standards and norms. Strategy fundamentally involves choices about what an organization values.
* AI systems are only as good as the data they are trained on: AI systems inherit biases in their training data and may perpetuate historical patterns rather than enable transformative change. For example, if historical data reflects discriminatory practices, AI may inadvertently perpetuate these biases in its strategic suggestions.
As organizations pursue their strategic planning and marketing & communications plans its important to remember that REAL BRAINS ARE GREATER THAN AI.
Yes .. there are AI programs out there that will walk you through the paces of this planning .. but will its recommendations be relevant? Will it involve all voices? Will it focus on YOUR problems?
...
A consultant like Beard Marketing Consulting can help you develop an effective strategic and marketing plans that are specifically tailored to your needs -- not a pre-processed, cookie-cutter, generic, AI-generated response.
Contact me when you're ready to make a plan that is relevant and executable to meet your goals and initiatives!
...
https://balancedscorecard.org/blog/augmented-strategy-the-promise-and-pitfalls-of-ai-in-strategic-planning/