06/18/2026
The marketing metrics that matter most finally came in green after a bit of a struggle, and you have to present this success to the board. Now, what do you do?
You waited three quarters, and you did your fair share of clawing to get there. The pipeline is up, the cohorts look healthy, and for once, you walk into the board meeting with good news instead of a defense.
You present the amazing results at the board meeting, and everyone nods. Someone says “nice work,” And then the conversation moves on, and you walk out, realizing the best quarter you ever had in a year just bought you almost nothing.
I have watched many CMOs pour all their preparation into delivering bad news when things are going wrong. They (rightfully so) obsess over how to frame the miss, when to raise the flag, how to walk into a hard room, and how to maintain the trust of everyone else in the meeting room when it all went south.
Funnier still is that most CMOs do not invest the same amount of thought and effort into how to deliver good news. This is the more costly blind spot because, unless you guide the narrative behind your win, the board will see it as a “minimum” win and won't know why it happened.
The next time your metrics dip (and they will), there will be no credibility with the board to help buffer you through the loss, and the same people who shrugged at the win are suddenly very interested in the loss.
The art of delivering good news is explaining the why behind it. When something works well before your next review, take on the hard task of figuring out exactly what went right and why. Some examples you may want to include: Which segment, motion, or two or three decisions actually drove the success?
Then bring that in-depth analysis to the board, not just the result. Explain to them what moved, why it moves, what it would take for you to extend it, and what return you could get from doing even more of it.
A green number explained methodically to the board stops being a pleasant surprise or worse, a point of apathy, and becomes a strong case for further marketing investment. It also banks the board’s trust in you, which you can spend later, in the quarter, the wind turns against you.
Most marketing leaders never get coached on this, because everyone assumes good news takes care of itself, but it doesn’t always.
I have helped many CMOs learn to deliver a win that compounds into the marketing budget and their standing within the company, rather than evaporating once the next slide is clicked.
If reporting on your good quarters is not something you really prepare for in the same vein as you do for reporting bad ones, you’re not alone at all. But it’s something you should take some time to work on.