05/30/2026
A client pushed back on me: "Why aren't we showing up for a certain keyword? That's the generic term. We should own it."
It felt like a reasonable argument.
Until I pulled the data.
Historical ACOS on that certain keyword: 300%.
Same keyword, different campaign: 220%.
Another test: 185%.
Then 150%.
We tried it four different times across four different campaigns.
Every single time, the broad term burned budget without converting.
The product was priced at a premium.
People typing in that keyword were comparison shopping at $6 to $12 price points.
We were not that product.
Meanwhile, a variation most people wouldn't think twice about — had a 4.33 ROAS over 30 days in the same period.
Broad generic keywords feel like they should work.
But relevance and intent win on Amazon, not volume alone.
I'd rather own ten specific, converting keywords than be invisible on one big one.
I'm graduating the performers into exact single-keyword campaigns now so I can push harder with more control.
Don't chase the keyword that sounds right.
Chase the data that proves it.